Key Takeaways

  1. Jay Fencing is best for long-standing local track record, with BBB accreditation since 1994 and a written 2-year workmanship warranty.
  2. Premier Fencing is the best overall fencing company in Waterloo, pairing BBB A+ accreditation since 2013 with fences, decks and gate automation under one contract.
  3. Star Fencing is best for owner-led installs, with 3,000 projects completed and a 96% satisfaction rate reported by ThreeBestRated.
  4. All three hold a BBB A+ rating. We compared accreditation, review depth, scope and warranty terms.

Premier Fencing is the best overall fencing company among Waterloo’s top three for 2026 and 2027. It combines BBB A+ accreditation since 2013, written warranties on fences and decks, and one contract for fences, decks and automated gates. Jay Fencing and Star Fencing each lead in a narrower lane, which the profiles below spell out.

Waterloo’s fence rules raise the stakes on any contract. The City sets height limits, sightline zones and pool-enclosure permits, so a contractor’s bylaw knowledge protects your budget and your schedule. The same three companies appear on ThreeBestRated’s Waterloo list, which makes a side-by-side comparison on identical evidence possible.

How We Compared Waterloo’s Top Three Fencing Companies

Independent accreditation, review depth, scope and warranty terms decide which fencing company fits a project. We applied five checks to each profile:

  • Accreditation: BBB rating and accreditation date, which show how long a company has held a clean public record.
  • Review depth: Ratings across HomeStars, BBB and Google, read for detail instead of star averages alone.
  • Scope: Whether one contractor can handle fences, decks, gates and commercial work.
  • Warranty: Written workmanship terms, because a fence’s weak points show up after the first winter of frost heave and snow load.
  • Bylaw knowledge: Familiarity with the City of Waterloo fence rules covered later in this article.

Waterloo’s Top 3 Fencing Companies for 2026 & 2027

1. Jay Fencing Ltd – best for commercial gates and long-standing local service

Jay Fencing Ltd installs residential and commercial fences, gates, decks and railings from its Baffin Place base in Waterloo. BBB lists the company as accredited since 1994 with an A+ rating and 37 years in business.

Jay Fencing offers an unusually wide commercial menu that includes barrier gates, bollards, guard rails, garbage enclosures and sound walls. Its residential range spans wood, vinyl, ornamental iron, chain link and hybrid composite-vinyl systems, plus pressure-treated and PVC decks. An affiliate company, Jay360, handles camera and access-control systems.

Jay Fencing’s 27 HomeStars reviews average 4 out of 5, and one reviewer rated 1/5 Stars on HomeStars Review

“The customer hired Jay’s Fencing to build a 22 × 12 ft. second-floor back deck for $15,000, expecting high-quality workmanship. Although communication before construction was good, the customer was disappointed with the finished result. The main complaint was a visibly misaligned centre ribbon board that did not line up with the centre support pole. When asked to correct the issue, Jay reportedly declined, explaining that the repair would be difficult.”

Where It Excels

  • BBB accredited since 1994 with an A+ rating
  • Barrier gates, bollards, guard rails and sound walls handled by one contractor
  • Written 2-year workmanship warranty
  • Listed among Waterloo’s top three fencing contractors on ThreeBestRated for 9+ years

Where It Falls Short

  • Its commercial-heavy menu suits larger sites more than a single small residential repair.

Best for: long-standing local track record, particularly commercial sites that need gates, bollards or sound walls.

Contact: 

Address: 70 Baffin Place, Waterloo, ON N2V 1Z7 

Phone: 519-747-3970 

2. Premier Fencing – best overall fencing company

Premier Fencing builds fences, decks, pergolas and automated gates for homes and commercial sites from its Colby Drive base in Waterloo. The range covers pressure-treated wood, cedar, vinyl, ornamental iron and chain link fencing, plus pool and pet fences, temporary construction fencing, composite and vinyl decks, helical piles and railings.

Premier grew out of Boyer Fence and Deck, a family trade lineage the company dates past 100 years. BBB records the current corporation from April 2012 under owner Daniel Boyer.

Premier has held BBB accreditation since 23 January 2013 with an A+ rating. ThreeBestRated has listed it among Waterloo’s top three fencing contractors for 9+ years.

Premier backs fences with a 2-year warranty and decks with a 5-year warranty, and many products it installs carry manufacturer coverage of up to 25 years. It partners with Yardistry, LiftMaster and DoorKing for pergolas and gate automation.

Premier’s HomeStars profile shows 4.5 out of 5 across 10 reviews, and named homeowners post detailed Google reviews that describe on-time installs and tidy job sites. A homeowner who compared three quotes rated 5/5 star on HomeStars described the pricing outcome:

“I’m so pleased that we chose Premier Fencing for our project. The price was good and the work and final product were excellent. All the installers were easy to communicate with and very professional. The two neighbours who share the new fence were very pleased with the result as well. I highly recommend Premier Fencing and have given permission for them to share my contact details as a reference.” – Scott Bartle, Guelph

Where It Excels

  • BBB A+ accredited since 2013
  • Fences, decks, pergolas and gate automation under one contract
  • 2-year fence warranty and 5-year deck warranty
  • Commercial scope that includes automated gates and temporary construction fencing

Where It Falls Short

  • Its one-contract scope delivers the most value on multi-feature backyard projects rather than a single-panel repair.

Best for: homeowners and commercial property managers who want fencing, decks and gates from one accredited contractor.

Contact: 

Address: 620 Colby Drive, Waterloo, ON N2V 1A2 

Phone: 519-500-5545 

3. Star Fencing Inc – best for owner-led fences, decks and gates

Star Fencing Inc builds residential and commercial fences, decks, gates and pergolas from its Bathurst Drive shop in Waterloo. BBB lists it as accredited since May 2022 with an A+ rating, and its owner appears on the profile as principal contact.

ThreeBestRated credits Star Fencing with 3,000 completed projects and 96% satisfied customers. Its HomeStars profile shows 4.4 out of 5 across 12 reviews, with detailed praise for on-the-spot quoting, polite crews and tidy cleanup.

Star Fencing offers wood in board-on-board, board-on-batten and horizontal styles, plus ornamental iron, vinyl, chain link and cedar fences. Its decks come in cedar, composite and pressure-treated wood, and it also installs railings, arbors, bollards and self-storage lockers. Recognition includes a Winners’ Circle Award, and the company sponsors the Kitchener Rangers, which signals a local presence beyond individual jobs.

Where It Excels

  • BBB A+ rating and accreditation since 2022
  • 3,000 completed projects at a 96% customer satisfaction rate
  • Three wood fence styles plus cedar, composite and pressure-treated decks
  • WSIB-compliant crews with a Winners’ Circle Award

Where It Falls Short

  • Its listed range centres on residential-scale wood, iron and vinyl work, so large commercial gate systems sit outside it.

Best for: owner-led installs, particularly homeowners who want a wood or iron fence with a matching deck.

Contact: 

Address: 235B Bathurst Drive, Unit B, Waterloo, ON N2V 2E4 

Phone: 519-745-1900 

Side-by-Side Comparison of Waterloo’s Top Three

Company Best for Core scope BBB

Accredited

since

Jay Fencing Long-standing local track record Commercial gates, bollards, sound walls 1994
Premier Fencing Overall fencing company Fences, decks, gate automation 2013
Star Fencing Owner-led installs Wood, iron and vinyl fences, decks 2022

What Waterloo’s Fence Rules Mean for Your Quote

The City of Waterloo caps fences at 2.44 m (8 ft) in rear and side yards under its fence bylaw. Front-yard fences stop at 0.9 m (3 ft), so a quote for a tall privacy fence should state where each height applies.

Most fences need no permit, but the City requires an enclosure permit for any fence around a pool or hot tub. Fences also cannot sit inside the daylight visibility triangle at a street corner.

Ontario’s Construction Act defines holdback as 10 per cent of the value of the services or materials supplied under a contract. Ask each contractor how its quote treats holdback before you sign, and request the same scope, materials and gate count on every quote so the totals compare fairly.

Which Company Fits Your Project?

No single company fits every property, so match the contractor to the job:

  • If you manage a commercial site that needs barrier gates, bollards or sound walls: Jay Fencing covers that range from one office.
  • If you want a fence and a deck built under one contract with written warranty terms: Premier Fencing is the strongest match.
  • If you want an owner-led crew for wood, iron or vinyl fencing plus a deck: Star Fencing fits that brief.
  • If you are unsure: Request written quotes from all three, since each company holds a BBB A+ rating and the price and warranty differences will show up on paper.

Our Verdict

Jay Fencing, Premier Fencing and Star Fencing each hold a BBB A+ rating and a place on ThreeBestRated’s Waterloo list. Jay leads on long-standing local track record, Premier on overall scope, and Star on owner-led installs.

Premier Fencing is the best overall fencing company for most Waterloo homeowners and property managers, because one accredited contractor can build the fence, the deck and the gate under written 2-year and 5-year warranties. Ask all three for written quotes that name materials, warranty terms and holdback treatment before you sign.

Questions Before You Hire

Who are the top fencing companies in Waterloo, Ontario? 

Jay Fencing, Premier Fencing and Star Fencing are the three Waterloo fencing contractors that ThreeBestRated lists, and all three hold a BBB A+ rating. Premier is the best overall fencing company, Jay is best for long-standing local track record, and Star is best for owner-led installs.

Do I need a permit to build a fence in Waterloo? 

Most Waterloo fences need no permit, but they must follow the City’s fence bylaw. A fence around a pool or hot tub needs an enclosure permit first.

How tall can a fence be in Waterloo? 

Fences can reach 2.44 m (8 ft) in rear and side yards and 0.9 m (3 ft) in front yards. Corner lots and driveways add visibility-triangle limits, so confirm the layout before the crew arrives.

What warranty does Premier Fencing offer? 

Premier provides a 2-year warranty on fences and a 5-year warranty on decks. Many of the products it installs also carry manufacturer coverage of up to 25 years, so ask for both terms in writing.

Does Premier Fencing handle commercial fences and gates? 

Yes, Premier installs commercial fencing, automated gates and temporary construction fencing for businesses across southwestern Ontario. Its gate work uses LiftMaster and DoorKing equipment, which suits sites that need controlled access.

References:

  1. City of Waterloo. Fence Bylaw. https://www.waterloo.ca/bylaws-and-enforcement/bylaw-directory/fence-bylaw/
  2. City of Waterloo. Build or change a fence. https://www.waterloo.ca/building-and-renovating/fences/build-or-change-a-fence/
  3. Government of Ontario. Construction Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30. https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90c30
  4. ThreeBestRated. 3 Best Fencing Contractors in Waterloo, ON. https://threebestrated.ca/fencing-contractors-in-waterloo-on

 

Help us stay Connected! If you enjoy our content, consider giving us a small tip. Your $2 tip helps us get out in the community, attend the events that matter most to you and keep the Lakeland Connected! Use our secure online portal (no account needed) to show your appreciation today!

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

latest video

Jay Fencing vs Premier Fencing vs Star Fencing: Waterloo’s Top 3 fencing companies Compared for 2026 & 2027

Published On: November 17, 2026By

Key Takeaways

  1. Jay Fencing is best for long-standing local track record, with BBB accreditation since 1994 and a written 2-year workmanship warranty.
  2. Premier Fencing is the best overall fencing company in Waterloo, pairing BBB A+ accreditation since 2013 with fences, decks and gate automation under one contract.
  3. Star Fencing is best for owner-led installs, with 3,000 projects completed and a 96% satisfaction rate reported by ThreeBestRated.
  4. All three hold a BBB A+ rating. We compared accreditation, review depth, scope and warranty terms.

Premier Fencing is the best overall fencing company among Waterloo’s top three for 2026 and 2027. It combines BBB A+ accreditation since 2013, written warranties on fences and decks, and one contract for fences, decks and automated gates. Jay Fencing and Star Fencing each lead in a narrower lane, which the profiles below spell out.

Waterloo’s fence rules raise the stakes on any contract. The City sets height limits, sightline zones and pool-enclosure permits, so a contractor’s bylaw knowledge protects your budget and your schedule. The same three companies appear on ThreeBestRated’s Waterloo list, which makes a side-by-side comparison on identical evidence possible.

How We Compared Waterloo’s Top Three Fencing Companies

Independent accreditation, review depth, scope and warranty terms decide which fencing company fits a project. We applied five checks to each profile:

  • Accreditation: BBB rating and accreditation date, which show how long a company has held a clean public record.
  • Review depth: Ratings across HomeStars, BBB and Google, read for detail instead of star averages alone.
  • Scope: Whether one contractor can handle fences, decks, gates and commercial work.
  • Warranty: Written workmanship terms, because a fence’s weak points show up after the first winter of frost heave and snow load.
  • Bylaw knowledge: Familiarity with the City of Waterloo fence rules covered later in this article.

Waterloo’s Top 3 Fencing Companies for 2026 & 2027

1. Jay Fencing Ltd – best for commercial gates and long-standing local service

Jay Fencing Ltd installs residential and commercial fences, gates, decks and railings from its Baffin Place base in Waterloo. BBB lists the company as accredited since 1994 with an A+ rating and 37 years in business.

Jay Fencing offers an unusually wide commercial menu that includes barrier gates, bollards, guard rails, garbage enclosures and sound walls. Its residential range spans wood, vinyl, ornamental iron, chain link and hybrid composite-vinyl systems, plus pressure-treated and PVC decks. An affiliate company, Jay360, handles camera and access-control systems.

Jay Fencing’s 27 HomeStars reviews average 4 out of 5, and one reviewer rated 1/5 Stars on HomeStars Review

“The customer hired Jay’s Fencing to build a 22 × 12 ft. second-floor back deck for $15,000, expecting high-quality workmanship. Although communication before construction was good, the customer was disappointed with the finished result. The main complaint was a visibly misaligned centre ribbon board that did not line up with the centre support pole. When asked to correct the issue, Jay reportedly declined, explaining that the repair would be difficult.”

Where It Excels

  • BBB accredited since 1994 with an A+ rating
  • Barrier gates, bollards, guard rails and sound walls handled by one contractor
  • Written 2-year workmanship warranty
  • Listed among Waterloo’s top three fencing contractors on ThreeBestRated for 9+ years

Where It Falls Short

  • Its commercial-heavy menu suits larger sites more than a single small residential repair.

Best for: long-standing local track record, particularly commercial sites that need gates, bollards or sound walls.

Contact: 

Address: 70 Baffin Place, Waterloo, ON N2V 1Z7 

Phone: 519-747-3970 

2. Premier Fencing – best overall fencing company

Premier Fencing builds fences, decks, pergolas and automated gates for homes and commercial sites from its Colby Drive base in Waterloo. The range covers pressure-treated wood, cedar, vinyl, ornamental iron and chain link fencing, plus pool and pet fences, temporary construction fencing, composite and vinyl decks, helical piles and railings.

Premier grew out of Boyer Fence and Deck, a family trade lineage the company dates past 100 years. BBB records the current corporation from April 2012 under owner Daniel Boyer.

Premier has held BBB accreditation since 23 January 2013 with an A+ rating. ThreeBestRated has listed it among Waterloo’s top three fencing contractors for 9+ years.

Premier backs fences with a 2-year warranty and decks with a 5-year warranty, and many products it installs carry manufacturer coverage of up to 25 years. It partners with Yardistry, LiftMaster and DoorKing for pergolas and gate automation.

Premier’s HomeStars profile shows 4.5 out of 5 across 10 reviews, and named homeowners post detailed Google reviews that describe on-time installs and tidy job sites. A homeowner who compared three quotes rated 5/5 star on HomeStars described the pricing outcome:

“I’m so pleased that we chose Premier Fencing for our project. The price was good and the work and final product were excellent. All the installers were easy to communicate with and very professional. The two neighbours who share the new fence were very pleased with the result as well. I highly recommend Premier Fencing and have given permission for them to share my contact details as a reference.” – Scott Bartle, Guelph

Where It Excels

  • BBB A+ accredited since 2013
  • Fences, decks, pergolas and gate automation under one contract
  • 2-year fence warranty and 5-year deck warranty
  • Commercial scope that includes automated gates and temporary construction fencing

Where It Falls Short

  • Its one-contract scope delivers the most value on multi-feature backyard projects rather than a single-panel repair.

Best for: homeowners and commercial property managers who want fencing, decks and gates from one accredited contractor.

Contact: 

Address: 620 Colby Drive, Waterloo, ON N2V 1A2 

Phone: 519-500-5545 

3. Star Fencing Inc – best for owner-led fences, decks and gates

Star Fencing Inc builds residential and commercial fences, decks, gates and pergolas from its Bathurst Drive shop in Waterloo. BBB lists it as accredited since May 2022 with an A+ rating, and its owner appears on the profile as principal contact.

ThreeBestRated credits Star Fencing with 3,000 completed projects and 96% satisfied customers. Its HomeStars profile shows 4.4 out of 5 across 12 reviews, with detailed praise for on-the-spot quoting, polite crews and tidy cleanup.

Star Fencing offers wood in board-on-board, board-on-batten and horizontal styles, plus ornamental iron, vinyl, chain link and cedar fences. Its decks come in cedar, composite and pressure-treated wood, and it also installs railings, arbors, bollards and self-storage lockers. Recognition includes a Winners’ Circle Award, and the company sponsors the Kitchener Rangers, which signals a local presence beyond individual jobs.

Where It Excels

  • BBB A+ rating and accreditation since 2022
  • 3,000 completed projects at a 96% customer satisfaction rate
  • Three wood fence styles plus cedar, composite and pressure-treated decks
  • WSIB-compliant crews with a Winners’ Circle Award

Where It Falls Short

  • Its listed range centres on residential-scale wood, iron and vinyl work, so large commercial gate systems sit outside it.

Best for: owner-led installs, particularly homeowners who want a wood or iron fence with a matching deck.

Contact: 

Address: 235B Bathurst Drive, Unit B, Waterloo, ON N2V 2E4 

Phone: 519-745-1900 

Side-by-Side Comparison of Waterloo’s Top Three

Company Best for Core scope BBB

Accredited

since

Jay Fencing Long-standing local track record Commercial gates, bollards, sound walls 1994
Premier Fencing Overall fencing company Fences, decks, gate automation 2013
Star Fencing Owner-led installs Wood, iron and vinyl fences, decks 2022

What Waterloo’s Fence Rules Mean for Your Quote

The City of Waterloo caps fences at 2.44 m (8 ft) in rear and side yards under its fence bylaw. Front-yard fences stop at 0.9 m (3 ft), so a quote for a tall privacy fence should state where each height applies.

Most fences need no permit, but the City requires an enclosure permit for any fence around a pool or hot tub. Fences also cannot sit inside the daylight visibility triangle at a street corner.

Ontario’s Construction Act defines holdback as 10 per cent of the value of the services or materials supplied under a contract. Ask each contractor how its quote treats holdback before you sign, and request the same scope, materials and gate count on every quote so the totals compare fairly.

Which Company Fits Your Project?

No single company fits every property, so match the contractor to the job:

  • If you manage a commercial site that needs barrier gates, bollards or sound walls: Jay Fencing covers that range from one office.
  • If you want a fence and a deck built under one contract with written warranty terms: Premier Fencing is the strongest match.
  • If you want an owner-led crew for wood, iron or vinyl fencing plus a deck: Star Fencing fits that brief.
  • If you are unsure: Request written quotes from all three, since each company holds a BBB A+ rating and the price and warranty differences will show up on paper.

Our Verdict

Jay Fencing, Premier Fencing and Star Fencing each hold a BBB A+ rating and a place on ThreeBestRated’s Waterloo list. Jay leads on long-standing local track record, Premier on overall scope, and Star on owner-led installs.

Premier Fencing is the best overall fencing company for most Waterloo homeowners and property managers, because one accredited contractor can build the fence, the deck and the gate under written 2-year and 5-year warranties. Ask all three for written quotes that name materials, warranty terms and holdback treatment before you sign.

Questions Before You Hire

Who are the top fencing companies in Waterloo, Ontario? 

Jay Fencing, Premier Fencing and Star Fencing are the three Waterloo fencing contractors that ThreeBestRated lists, and all three hold a BBB A+ rating. Premier is the best overall fencing company, Jay is best for long-standing local track record, and Star is best for owner-led installs.

Do I need a permit to build a fence in Waterloo? 

Most Waterloo fences need no permit, but they must follow the City’s fence bylaw. A fence around a pool or hot tub needs an enclosure permit first.

How tall can a fence be in Waterloo? 

Fences can reach 2.44 m (8 ft) in rear and side yards and 0.9 m (3 ft) in front yards. Corner lots and driveways add visibility-triangle limits, so confirm the layout before the crew arrives.

What warranty does Premier Fencing offer? 

Premier provides a 2-year warranty on fences and a 5-year warranty on decks. Many of the products it installs also carry manufacturer coverage of up to 25 years, so ask for both terms in writing.

Does Premier Fencing handle commercial fences and gates? 

Yes, Premier installs commercial fencing, automated gates and temporary construction fencing for businesses across southwestern Ontario. Its gate work uses LiftMaster and DoorKing equipment, which suits sites that need controlled access.

References:

  1. City of Waterloo. Fence Bylaw. https://www.waterloo.ca/bylaws-and-enforcement/bylaw-directory/fence-bylaw/
  2. City of Waterloo. Build or change a fence. https://www.waterloo.ca/building-and-renovating/fences/build-or-change-a-fence/
  3. Government of Ontario. Construction Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30. https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90c30
  4. ThreeBestRated. 3 Best Fencing Contractors in Waterloo, ON. https://threebestrated.ca/fencing-contractors-in-waterloo-on

 

Help us stay Connected! If you enjoy our content, consider giving us a small tip. Your $2 tip helps us get out in the community, attend the events that matter most to you and keep the Lakeland Connected! Use our secure online portal (no account needed) to show your appreciation today!

latest video

you might also like

news via inbox

Get Connected! Sign up for daily news updates.