Federal Court Ruling Opens the Door to First Nations Financial Transparency

Frog Lake activist’s case now a national precedent

 

A Frog Lake First Nation activist who first gained notoriety by posting about financial concerns on TikTok has now set a legal precedent that could reshape financial transparency in First Nations communities across Canada.

 

A case that started with missing money

 

Years ago, Hans McCarthy noticed something was wrong in his home community. The trust fund—built from band revenues tied to natural resources—had once held more than $100 million. By 2024, it had dropped to less than $9 million.

 

Unsatisfied with the lack of answers, McCarthy reached out to the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. With the support of CTF Prairie Director Gage Haubrich, they filed access to information requests to locate Band Council resolutions that should have documented where the money went.

 

The federal government refused to release them.

 

Taking Ottawa to court

 

In 2022, McCarthy and the CTF launched a Federal Court application arguing that both the federal government and local First Nations leaders have a duty to provide transparency when a band member asks for it.

 

Three years later, the Federal Court agreed.

 

Indigenous Services Canada has 30 days to release the requested documents to McCarthy.

 

What transparency could mean for communities

 

McCarthy said knowing where the money went will help answer community questions and rebuild trust. Transparency, he added, could lead to better housing, education, programming, and governance.

 

“When you get rid of that corruption out there and you have transparency, it gives information to band members on who to vote for,” he said.

 

Since the ruling, McCarthy has heard from band members across Canada and even the United States. The ripple effect is already underway.

 

A national precedent

 

Haubrich said the decision sets a clear standard: when First Nations members want financial records, the federal government must disclose them.

 

Band members in other communities seeking similar documents will now have a far easier path than McCarthy did.

 

While the CTF continues to speak with other First Nations communities, it has not confirmed whether similar cases are underway.

 

The ruling marks a major shift in accountability and signals a new era of financial clarity for First Nations across the country.

 

…